Friday, 29 October 2021

Insulate Britain the idiots' way.

The cost of what Insulate Britain want is £360 and £600 billion according to their numbers. That is between 12 & 20 Hinkley C reactors or to put in another watt 39,120MWe & 65,200 MWe, that even when you allow for £30 billion per plant when the current costs is estimated as between 21 & 22.


According to the National grid peak demand up to October 2021 was over a day was 36.01 GW. The installed capacity is 75.8 GW and up to 75% of that has been used in the past that is 56GW. 

Most of the time that can be filled by less than 50% of the installed environmental energy or by using some of the UK's 32 GW of gas-powered generation fuelled by hydrogen or synthetic methane produced during periods of excess. 

If you ordered 12 plants you'd save a lot of cash by allowing some small production runs, the government could have even more if it used its own methods for raising the money.

Of course, currently under development are
Small Modular Reactors(SMR) technologies which should be cheaper.

The UK also has environmental energy at about 11,749 MW, so for the lower estimated cost by Insulate

Britain, we can eliminate all fossil fuels from Electricity and have 11,749 MW leftover for Synthetic gas production and CCU at the top end we can have 37,829 MW left over. That is without allowing for economies of scale, SMR being cheaper or added environmental energy.

Any impression that Insulate Britain are a collection of has been Dark Greens with outmoded thinking is only reinforced by their willingness to shoot themselves in the foot. Of the UK's energy production 30% goes on domestic heating, so were as the nuclear solution could eliminate all fossil electricity production and provide all the electrical power we need and more, insulation still leaves us looking for ways to produce at least 20,000MW.

Tuesday, 3 August 2021

4 solid walls.

Liverpool is a city built on 4 solid walls, to be precise 4 solid walls of silence. The one you will hear about most of is the general one where people don't help the police doesn't matter how shit the crooks make your life, don't help the police, Brian Ashton is a strong exponent of this.

The second 1 is in the police, never grass up your colleagues no matter what they have done, by all means, give them nicknames like "The Rapist" and when they get caught pretend they were never really police anyway.

In LCC you also never grass up your colleagues no matter how badly they treat the public and no matter how much they lie, you can also rely on large numbers of cops to help with this one as you are all in public service. Remember as a council staff member it is your city and you get to call the shots.

The final one is the one in the Echo when you can be called by a journo from the Echo and have all sorts of wild allegations angrily thrown at you. When you point out some of the simple factual errors like your place of birth and schooling they get more hesitant as it becomes clear they have been fed a pack of nonsense by someone. Do they apologise for doing someone's dirty work and help get to the bottom of what has caused this abuse, of course not, they just hang up, but that Al in a days work.
When you complain to the editor one Al Machray, he repeats some other rubbish angrily and surprise surprise can't find no record of your number being called and insist it didn't happen.

You can rely on the likes of the other Al's at the echo, together with the Gow's to bring things up every so often just to keep stirring.
If the people of Liverpool had any sense they'd boycott the Echo as much as they do the sun.

If there is a roof on this room it's provided by the security guards, eager to please anyone in power who might overlook their dodgy behaviour.


Monday, 2 August 2021

Simply the Worst

This route is 5:30 minutes with no WiFi or power and to make matters worse it is on the slowest possible route. Well equal slowest but you have to go via Lincoln to get to the same time

Just to given an idea of how appalling this route is I worked out all the alternatives which turn out to be something like.

or in the real world.

Note the lines in black on the map below, no longer exist but would make the journey quicker. The red bypass under Derby has no passenger services so all timings involve 5 minutes turn around in Derby, there was a bit of track to allow a turn east while passing through Derby north but that has gone.


After messing around with the National Rail route planner and discovering it is very buggy and very limited and totally unfriendly I got these timings. These are for the fastest journeys between various points, you cannot make these journeys at this speed now because you'd have long gaps waiting for connections. 

 The UK rail system is now so messed up you cannot do a lot of the routes without multiple tickets. By a strange fluke, the slowest route I could find has exactly the same time as the current direct route and in order to do that, I had to go via Lincoln, at least no reversing at Sheffield. The current route is the slowest possible route. If the route through Bakewell ever reopens that will be physically the shortest but unlikely the fastest.

Another possible route would be Liverpool->Chester->Crewe using the Halton curve. that would add about 35 minutes to the Liverpeel Crewe section.

The British Rail Class 755 would seem ideally suited to the journey, the current trains are British_Rail_Class_158.

CrossCountry would be the ideal operator for this.

Monday, 28 December 2020

Food, Fuel and Plastic from pollution

Carbon is used for many things and a lot of that carbon is acquired from oil, it makes a lot of sense to use Carbon obtained from direct air capture to make those products.

Plastics are some of the most common materials over 311 million tonnes are various plastics are produced every year, of that 230 million tonnes is carbon.

It is not a vast  amount as just under 3% of global CO2 output, the equivalent of 33.8 million mature trees. One of the problems is in breaking the CO2 bonds recently a new Technique doubles conversion of CO2 to plastic component.

NASA long had an ambition to turn astronauts CO2  waste into food and a Finnish company has managed the trick see Food from thin air. This flour like product would be a good replacement for soya flour,which is currently decimating the amazon basin. 

There have also been recent improvements in the processes for converting CO2 into long chain hydrocarbons suitable for jet engines and potentially other heavy fuel systems like diesel.

 New Iron-based Catalyst Converts Carbon Dioxide into Jet Fuel

Wednesday, 9 December 2020

Freedom from AntiVaxers.

I want the right to refuse to have unvaccinated people with no medical reason in my flat and if I had a shop in my shop.
You want the right not to risk a vaccine, I want the right not to be exposed to your potential mutant infection. Having an endemic infection caused by people who choose not to be vaccinated, not only means that people who cannot be vaccinated are at risk, it means increases the number of mutations, mutations that will inevitably lead to a bypassing of the effectiveness of the vaccine.
As usual, a lot of the anti-vax stuff is from the libertarian right, which wants people to be free to do the things that libertarian right-wingers approve of but not the things other more socially-minded people approve of.
If the owner of any establishment bans those who are voluntarily unvaccinated, what legal recourse do they have if those banned enter? Is it trespass or assault? Being unvaccinated for some will be a choice, a choice that has long term consequences for others, they are seeking to impose themselves but will moan continually about their loss of freedom with no consideration of the freedom of others.
In a free society, everyone must make compromises to allow the freedom of others, the Anti-vaxers will entertain no compromise by them.

Tuesday, 1 December 2020

Liverpool International Railway Station


One of the questions that come up every so often is "If Liverpool gets an HS2/NPR connection where will the station be?". It is a difficult question to answer, Steve Rotheram and the LCR have effectively ruled out expanding Lime Street, saying it is simply not possible, and I completely agree. This hasn't stopped some people, who seem more interested in the architecture than the practicality of the solution.

It is important to set out the requirements for a proper connection. For me, this is full length 400m GC gauge trains. The LCR has added close proximity to Lime Street and the existing station to that I'd add it needs to be outside the loop for practical reasons.

The space we need is defined by the with of a GC Gauge carriage,  which is 3.29m, the platforms at a minimum of 12m with an extra meter for wiggle room giving a total of 19.58m per 2 line set. For simplicity let's call it 20m.

The absolute minimum number of platforms is 4 this assumes HS2 & NPR, in reality adding some extra platforms for intentional and classic long-distance makes sense, so a more realistic size is 6 or 8 platforms. this would allow for reasonable expansion or transfer of all long-distance express trains to the new station. Leavening regional and semi-fast for Lime street & local for Central station. This means we are looking for a site 60m or 80m wide.


I do have a site in mind which fore fills all the requirements with perhaps up to 100m available if a small amount of pavement is taken. That site is currently occupied by the Mount Pleasant Car Park and the 051 nightclub, between Mount Pleasant and Brownlow Hill.

Taking 80m line and extending 450m forward takes the end of the platforms to under the cathedral.


The land climbs from the Lime street and is some 10 meters higher by May Street several meters of headspace would be needed for this interface. Having 2 concourses allows the lower concourse at the platform end to be a reasonable size and to be constructed in a pit providing a cliff-like at May Street for the tunnelling to start, meeting the incoming 2 line tunnel.

Constructing an 80m span underground would be challenging.  Leaving supporting walls or building the walls would make the task easier, 3 walls each of 1m would add only 3m to the overall width and arranged as below they would provide fireproof divides between each platform in the underground section. 

Track layout.



Since the King's Cross fire there have been very strict rules for underground stations design to reduce the risks from fire. One of these is for excellent ventilation, to remove fumes, while the upper booking hall would prevent natural vertical ventilation, it could be provided lateral or vertically at the edge.
This would be unlikely to provide sufficient ventilation for the platforms. To accomplish this providing force extraction/insertion via vertical shafts at the end of the platforms could provide the needed throughput for the platforms with the Lower concourse side vents providing the entrance or exit points.
This would leave the area above the concourses free for use as a significant building.


Providing access to Liverpool's other main stations via travelators could utilise the existent access to central from the basement of Lewis's.

A station of this size would likely mean that other than an expansion of Liverpool central no new station would be needed for 100 years. Providing support for an international connection via the channel tunnel.

Full Connection

I know that currently HS2 plans barely include Liverpool as anything other than a minor adjunct but here are several plans for a dedicated Liverpool line from 20 Miles More to my own far cheaper plan here at Lymm to Lime Street.


Wednesday, 16 September 2020

Thetford to Norwich in 200 years.

In a fit of boredom, I plotted out a Thetford Norwich canal to bring Norwich into the 18th century and Thetford the 17th. If for some reason you want the KMZ Thetford-Norwich Canal.kmz. 

The high point is just south-east of Wymondham College north-west of London Road. Great Britain topographic map, elevation, relief

If I could find a decent overlay for google earth with contour lines I might be able to find a slightly better route or at least align it better with the rivers. The bits either side of the peak should be smooth as they follow water courses and there are, as far as I know no rapids or wiers on the route.

It is the Thet canalised from Thetford to the north side of the A11 near Besthorpe then a link across for further canalisation to Dyke Beck->To the River Tiffey which feeds into the Yare near Great Melton. In a Kayak your portage might be as little at 1.5 miles.

The Little Ouse Waveney route would look like

In the past there where plans to link Thetford with Bishop Stortford via the Little Ouse or Stor but the railways killed them off.  That would have linked Thetford to London. Another less detailed plan would have linked Thetford to the Waveney, via the little Ouse, this would have brought a connection to Lowestoft.

This is the Waveney route, it follows the Little Ouse then the Waveney The lack of a central summit means this has far less rise and if your desire was to connect to the ports this would be the way to go. it also connects to Beccles. The route is 99% the Norfolk Suffolk border.

Today though I think you would go for the Norwich route for a better broads connection it would be more tourist-friendly and would also be a better connection if the inland waterways are brought back to life by robotic traffic by even the standards of the 18th Century the summit at Attleborough is rather low and would require no more than 20 locks over the length of the canal.

If you want the google earth file it is LittleOuse-Waveney.kmz

If Thetford was connected to the canal network, though recently the last few miles is not supposed to be navigable, it may well be for small boats. This link would give access from east to west Liverpool & Wales to the Broads.

Monday, 7 September 2020

State of The Synthetic Hydrocarbon Art

Some of the first steps in the replacement of fossil hydrocarbons with synthetics and the journey has started in am oil rich country, Norway. From January, jet fuel in Norway must contain 0.5% of biofuel, at the moment the cost is four times the cost of fossil fuel.This fuel must be made of waste fats and vegetable oil, but not palm oil. SAS have a stated aim of powering all it domestic flights by biofuel. Norway plans to increase the required proportion to 30% by 2030.

This is obviously unsustainable for the entire aviation industry. Which means Europe’s first power-to-liquid demo plant in Norway plans renewable aviation fuel production in 2023. makes sense.

This uses the techniques outline in my blog Extinction Rebellion's biggest mistake but chemistry doesn't stand still. In February, Waseda University  in Japan announced.

Scientists developed a new method to convert carbon dioxide to methane with an electric field at low temperatures. In comparison to previous methods, this new method can produce any amount of methane whenever necessary. Because methane is a valuable gas which can be used to generate heat and electricity, this method could be exploited to help reduce the use of fossil fuels and prevent global warming.

The process drops the temperature of the conversion from 300-400°C to 100°C, not only does this use a different catalyst but also adds an electric field. Reducing the temperature required gives a large reduction in the energy required. The conversion to methane is only half of the 2 energy intense processes involves in making methane.

The other energy intense process is the production of hydrogen from water and that is currently an area of intense research as not only does it have bearing on the production of synthetic hydrocarbons but hydrogen is a potential energy in its own right. Only its low density and difficulty in storage make it a less than ideal fuel. The Royal Society gave 4 options given in "Options for producing low-carbon hydrogen at scale".
They are Thermochemical Routes to Hydrogen, Electrolytic Routes to Hydrogen, Biological Routes to Hydrogen and Solar to Fuels Routes to Hydrogen all of which have their niche usage. The ball has begun to move.

There is also artificial photosynthesis a process which looks to perform the complete production in a single device a synthetic leaf.

Sickesair https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/deed.en

Sunday, 23 August 2020

Ground assets

In the past in posts such as Nimrod Reborn and Vulcan B4, I have inexpertly considered how the RAF might acquire some larger aircraft at a reasonable price. They way any price can be made more reasonable is by getting more for your money, in terms of functionality. If you have something as capable as the aircraft outlined then you want to make maximum use of them, preferably without shortening their useful life with added fatigue.

One of the things the impressed me about the Victor was that the flight engineer could start the engines before getting in the aircraft via a panel on the hatch. This made a lot of sense when the aircraft was on Quick Reaction Alert, every second counted. I did wonder why the hardstanding didn't have a cable to connect the aircraft to the Crew Ready Room and the start up done that bit earlier.

 There may be some good reason for it but it could just have been to complicated for the era. Today commercial airliners are supplied with power while they are on the ground from onboard APU for short periods and Ground Power Units for longer. They is considerable pressure to move to Fixed Ground Power, where the aircraft is supplied from mains. This has the advantage of less kit on the apron as well as being potentially greener. So any modern aircraft military or otherwise I would expect to be capable of have an external connection.

The updates for aircraft systems are usually physically delivered to the aircraft vis USB fob or similar, this has some obvious security, similarly flight plans are loaded in the same way. On British Air Ways and perhaps other airlines Quick access recorder use physical means and beyond that wireless means to off load data, as this doesn't have security implications. Rolls Royce use satellites to relay data in near real time, while the engine is flying. This allows early diagnoses and pre-emptive repair. While the level of comms might not be appropriate for a military aircraft on active service, it would useful when not and with onboard data logging could still be provided after the flight.

If we have a power supply to the aircraft on the ground why not a high speed network connection. We can use that to uploaded and downloaded data and monitor the aircraft's systems to enhance availability. We might even go further. 

The modern aircraft is a mass of sensors and computers, being able to utilise them whilst on the ground be potentially useful. Passive IR watching at the sky, RWRs listening. Use of the aircraft's Tactical Data Links  to provide redundant communications. With the right aircraft it self-defence system chaff and flares could also be used.

In today's world of lock after launch it might even be possible to use some of the weapons on the aircraft, the Jaguars over wing pylons would have made that far easier but improved airfield defence is something worth having, not just against aerial targets, When push comes to shove an unflyable helicopter with Brimstone attached and under remote and secure control is a formidable machine.

A system similar to Berkeley Open Infrastructure for Network Computing could make use of any spare CPU power, which you can never have to much of. This on top of being able to start the engines remotely in an emergency and in the case of UAVs have them take off.

If only I could think of a way for a landing UAV to plug itself in to power and fuel the you could have a far sleeker ground operation.

At 1:56 there is a missile launch from an overwing pylon.

Thursday, 2 July 2020

Zilog on.

While it may surprise some of you not only do Zilog still exists but they still make the Z80 as well as a host of other chips variously based on it. I recently pulled to buts a broken soldering iron only to find a Zilog microcontroller in there. Likely your TV has one. I put tother a few symbols for KiCad for the Z80, Z180, Z380, eZ80 and a few others and stored them as Z80-CPU-for-KiCADon GitHub.
I've done some Z8 but the collection of them is massive so it will be a long time before they are done. If at all, some of the ones I have done are below.

  • Z80
  • Z180 
  • Z280
  • Z380
  • eZ80
  • Z8
  • CIO
  • KIO
  • DART
  • SIO
  • Z16c32
  • Z16c35
  • Z53c80
  • Z8536
  • Z8l382
  • Z85c30
  • Z08530
  • Z08536
  • Z16c30
  • Z80230
  • Z80380

The Z380, an 8-bit chip with 4 gigabytes of memory space, is the best.

L2R Z8, Z80, Z180, Z380 & eZ80
That 16g was an unthinkably large amount of memory about 16,000 times bigger than you average PC at the time(1994), now a single SRAM chip does it all for £110.

Friday, 29 May 2020

Journalism v Onanism

News' journalists are getting quite a hard time at the moment and at the top, they do a vital job or should do of holding the powerful to account but that only covers a small percentage of the trade. Below the national organisations like the BBC, CNN and the broadsheet papers we have the greatest mass of journalists working from the Tabloids downward including free news, local papers right down to press release republishers.
Some of the local papers may hold the odd councillor or cop to justice once in a while but their stock in trade is a crime, the more sordid the better, and local scandal, all coloured by a village jingoism. When a local gangster is shot they are a businessman when some low life dies in a gang on gang warfare they are lovely people who loved their mother and everyone got on with and had an infectious smile.
When it comes to the truth then it what they can print without being sued that passes for the truth, this is to some extent true of bigger papers but they are tackling bigger prey which often has access to my learned and very expensive friends. The further down you go the less supervision and the less likely to have access to courts or lawyers demanding a right of reply.
In short, they play to their audience which over the years has retreated to D & E social grade, you find spurious claims of things invented locally or specialities and for a promo, it will not be half price Beaujolais nouveau but Tennets or perhaps Stella. Down here is not the glamours side of journalism but it is by no means the bottom of the barrel.
Down at the bottom are the people who republish press releases with the most minor of changes and if your lucky some checks for accuracy. These are common in a lot of fields often staff by journalists forced out of the marginally more respectable press by the cost-cutting brought about by the likes of Google. The thing that determines publication here is not the fear of libel but they fear of copyright.
The one thing that is most obvious about this transition is as you move further down the more the journalists think of themselves as Woodward or Bernstein, quite often both with a bit of Paul Foot thrown in.
Even at the national level, there are problems, you can watch Piers Morgan defending journalists left,  right and centre, this is a man sacked for faking stories. The prime minister is still considered a journalist after being sacked at least 3 times according to the Independent.
That those 2 could still get jobs as journalists, tells us something about the trade and integrity if journalists want to be take as they want to and act as seriously as we need them to then they need to start being disassociating themselves from the likes of Piers and go.
If a journalist asks you "Are you guilty" do not answer "I am not" because is some papers they will happily truncate it and use the partial quote as justification. Journalists need to be talked to in the same way a solicitor advises people to talk to the police or the way Dominic Cummings reads out statements to journalists.
Journalists if you want to do your job sort out your own house.

Tuesday, 28 April 2020

Raspberry PI Hat CAD files

I needed to design a Raspberry PI hat and after looking around it appears there are no official releases. What I've done is take the DXF file for the PI 3 board and moved one edge. The position of the mounts and the connector is from the original. I've uploaded blanks to get hub as PIHat if anyone needs them.

If you want to improve them let me know and I'll make the git hup accessible to you.

Saturday, 12 October 2019

Extinction Rebellion's biggest mistake

One of the cries of extinction rebellion has been "Listen to the scientists" but they only want to listen to the diagnosis, when it comes to a cure it does not listen to the scientists. See Jet fuel from thin air: Aviation's hope or hype? 
The solution they offer is the same one that has been offered to every generation by some group or other a return to nature, the solution never varies only the problem changes. It is the same snake oil elixir that been offered by The Romantic Movement, the Hippys, Arts and Crafts movement, Conservatives the world over etc etc

One general law of physics is that if you have enough energy you can do just about anything. We have several potential sources of no carbon energy the environment and nuclear fission with a third nuclear fusion under development. The first part of any solution is going to be based on large amounts of power generation, via these sources, we can start building them now, start developing more systems and move first to more electrically based power.
There are of problems with the energy capacity of battery storage. Highlight by this graphic.
You see that battery storage is down at the bottom left, this is not a good place to be, it means that to store the energy for a long journey or with a heavy load you need a lot of space and mass for the batteries.
Hydrogen, by comparison, is very good at storing energy in terms of mass but very bad in terms of volume only liquid hydrogen, out of the 3 hydrogen storage types,  beats batteries in volume per joule and is way behind diesel, etc. For an aircraft, this creates a problem you have to have big tanks which either add drag or eat into internal space. Liquid hydrogen is also very cold so cold it can freeze liquid oxygen. Liquid methane which can be made from hydrogen via the Sabatier process is not as mass efficient as hydrogen but is better in terms of volume and temperature, both these fuels were tested in the 1980s by the Soviet Union on the Tu-155 and were successful.
We can extract hydrogen from water by electrolysis, it is also produced as a by-product of some chemical reactions, it, of course, takes electricity to perform electrolysis. Hydrogen from sunlight is a relatively new technology that can avoid the electrical stage and shows promise of being more efficient than electrolysis from electricity generated by photovoltaics.
To make Methane from hydrogen, via the Sabatier process,  you can use CO2 captured from the atmosphere but it takes energy to both captures the carbon and to convert it. You can also turn that methane into jet fuel or diesel via the Fischer–Tropsch process. The first was discovered in 1897 the later in the 1920s. Fuel advertised as GTL Fuel ultra-low sulphur diesel such as Shell's GTL is made by the Fischer–Tropsch process suggesting that most of the energy cost is in making the methane, as GTL fuel is readily available.
We could simply capture the carbon as CO2 and pump it underground and take the equivalent amount of natural gas. This would make sense if the energy used to capture and convert the CO2 is greater than the cost of extracting and cleaning the natural gas. To improve the levels of CO2 you might be required to pump more CO2 into the ground than extracted as natural gas.
Rather than go through the Sabatier process, the mixture could be made into syngas for the manufacture of plastics. While there are concerns about single-use plastic items, large amounts of plastic are used in items which benefit from the longevity of plastics. Making plastic from atmospheric carbon will lock that carbon up in the insulation of wires, window frames, and household appliances. It can be recycled via thermal depolymerization but that is another subject.
Crude oil is very complex and contains many chemicals which are used in a wide variety of ways which do not add to global warming but if the switch is made to using atmospheric carbon to make some of these product it might still be sensible to extract some crude oil for the more complex ones, but if atmospheric carbon is pumped underground to replace the fossil carbon at a 1:1 rate this would end up reducing atmospheric carbon as a percentage of the carbon from the oil will never enter the atmosphere. Mandating that a greater amount of carbon is pumped into the ground will ensure faster carbon reduction.
Even where the technology exists to replace hydrocarbons with batteries we would have to build a lot of new infrastructures and retire others before its expiry date. The synthetic fuels burn cleaner than fossil fuel, every litre stored in the supply system is carbon locked up. Replacing that infrastructure has a carbon cost attached to it as the replacement will likely use fossil source energy in the manufacture. It makes sense to consider a move to synthetic fuels and only replace old infrastructure when it is either time expired as that will use the least energy.

Southern Ocean

The transmission of electricity at the moment and likely forever requires cables and with the cables, unless they are superconducting comes losses, this renders some parts of the planet that are rich in environmental energy unexploitable. In the case of the southern ocean, the cables would have to also pass at extreme depth. One possible way of getting around this is to capture the energy via tidal, wave and wind power and convert it into synthetic fuel in situ either on the islands in that ocean or in floating mother ships of a size similar to Prelude FLNG. This could process the electricity into synthetic fuel that can be moved around to were it is needed.
Bar the last idea the import things is electricity generation the first thing that any government interested in reducing climate change should do is invest in electricity product from clean system not just enough to meet current needs but an amount that looks like oversupply then as the other technologies improve we can focus on using that supply to reduce atmospheric carbon by any means possible. Changing the way we live will not solve the problem, biofuels unless made from the waste product will only make the problem worse.

Third best

Some might say this is not the best solution to them I say

If you don't know who Robert Watson-Watt was then you should. The situation and threat we face are worse than the ones he did, the need for a solution is greater.

Stop Press 2013

I have been informed of the existence of this paper, from 2013. Since then Direct Carbon Capture has come a long way.

See Also

State of The Synthetic Hydrocarbon Art

Friday, 11 January 2019

A Phoenix from the ashes on Upper Parliament street.

For a bit of background see this blog from over 18 months ago.
It has been reborn as 18F/3306 Land on Upper Parliament St between Mulgrave St and Kingsley Rd SchoolL8 by the same developer.
The height of the buildings has been reduced by 1 story and there slight fewer flats. Various paths have been reduced to allow more green space and the street plant is up so maintaining the number of trees. A break in the building provides a path through the development address the concerns of the residents.
The objections raised seem to have been dealt with 1 by 1 making it very difficult to raise new objections but I'm sure this will happen a debate on the subject is already going on here amongst those likely to support the development.
I prefer the old development but will happily support this. I attended the planning meeting and the developers have addressed all the planning concerns, I doubt it will stop those with the more bizarre or unreasonable objections trying to stop.
Hopefully, the rebirth of Upper Parliament street as a proper thoroughfare is underway.

Update. The new application if before the planning committee on the 18th of June 2019. See Land on Upper Parliament St between Mulgrave St and Kingsley Rd SchoolL8 


This was passed on the 18 June.

Renders from the developer's application.

Saturday, 24 February 2018

Dictatorship of the proletariat

The dictatorship of the proletariat is not the same as the dictatorship of an individual prole but a lot seem to think it is. There is an argument that when some development or other does not suit some of the locals then it cannot be supported by socialists. Only capitalists would spoil your view, only capitalists would develop on the bit of land near you.  For some sections of society, who believe themselves to the archetype working class, then anything which happens that is not what they want, cannot be socialists, after all as members of the working class they are in control.
If you think you genuinely socialist society will not do things that you do not like you are delusional. The principle of socialism is the greatest good for the greatest number. If, by whatever mechanism, it is decided that more housing is needed and that bit of land by you, is a good spot for it, then as a good socialist you have to consider the value of this argument and acquiesce if the building is needed. In today mixed society, simply not liking the people doing the building is not an argument against that building being done.
In a socialist society, it is just as likely to be your neighbourhood plot of land that is developed as it is under capitalism, socialism is not a justification for NIMBYism. NIMBYism is a conservative trait, a selfish trait, if you are prosocial housing, you cannot be anti it being next to you.

Tuesday, 5 December 2017

Why do these people hate Liverpool

Popped along to the planning committee to see how a development I supported was going to fair, it is a couple of hundred yards from my flat. It is a great candidate for development, all of Liverpool would benefit from the improvement it would make to the approach down Parliament street.
It was rejected.
One of the opponents of the project was sitting in front of me and was at one point nearly ejected herself for her shouts of "rampant gentrification" and "it because we are ruled by white male patriarchy", and they were the quality arguments against. The Councillors of this city have stopped standing up to the ignorant baying mob and have become its vassals.
They complained about how little green space there was in the area, this despite the map behind showing Crown Street park, Falkner square and the corner of Prince's park.
Tony Conception was one who voted against, I said "congratulation another victory for incoherent gibberish" as I passed him on the way to the toilet.

The councillors of this city have a lot to answer for in destroying what is good and at the same time preserving what is not. They are, by and large, craven cowards incapable of putting the city and its population as a whole above the unfounded fears of a bunch of NIMBY Luddites, who now have a new collection of slogans to shout out, regardless of context or meaning. A similar thing happened with a Kirkdale development.

The Campaign for the Protection of Rural England also got involved, no explanation from them as to why they have moved from protecting the rural to protecting inner-city brownfield sites.
The barbarians are not just at the gate, they are on the planning committee.
See Skyscraper City for more background.


22/01/2018: After 2 weeks of trying to get an explanation out of the CPRE there has been no significant reply, no explanation for their actions.


11/01/2018: An updated application by the same developer has been put in see here.

It was approved.

The development

Some historic pictures of the area

The Junction Upper Parliament Street, Embledon Street, Toxteth, L.8 - 1955 Slightly further up than the proposed site.

Even in the early 70s, the south side of the street was intact large buildings similar to the ones that exist further down the hill. from A sense of place.
Upper Parliament Street with Bloom Street, where the Hospital is now.

and in Upper Parliament st at Bloom st in 1968
Same corner from Montpellier Terrace 1960s. note the background houses on the right.

Saturday, 2 September 2017

James Street

One advantage of the strike is you can get a good look at Platform 2 at James Street.

Saturday, 22 July 2017

Kirkdale impasse

Kirkdale sits to the north of Liverpool city centre, it stretches all the way from Leeds street to the border with Sefton and from the River to Scotland Road & Walton Vale. It used to be a densely packed area and was often described as having "great community spirit" but that also went with "great sectarian violence".
Kirkdale centred on the site of application 17F/0587


It was an area with great pockets of the deepest poverty, the earliest records of my paternal grandfather's family have all 7 of them living in a cellar on Limekiln Lane. Each floor of the house would be rented out to different families, I believe it was the English who got the ground floor and the Scots the upper, though it may be the other way around, whichever way it was the English got the best floor. Oh, and by floor, this could be a single room and the stairs would be a ladder.
My earliest memories of the area date from the early 70s getting a bus through the area it was a bit run down but largely intact. The main roads were lined the entire length by buildings mostly terraces with shops on the ground floor and the occasional ornate pub.
Towards the end of the 70s when my family got a car I can remember going along Vauxhall and I swear I remember the heat when driving past the Tate and Lyle refinery. Further, at around Marybone, there was a petrol station but under a set of offices.


Drive down either Scotland Road or Stanley Road and then you are in for a grim journey, what was once an entirely built-up area of terraces both great and small, is now a patchwork of derelict land, grassed over with the odd tree and interspersed with the corpses of roads that ran through it. The residential part used to be to the east of Vauxhall Road to the west of the was industrial and the docks, most of the industry is gone as is the housing to the east. In place of the Tate and Lyle factory has sprung up the Eldonian Village a scab of semi-detached suburbia, taking what should be prime sites for offices or industry.
You'll often hear complaints that areas like Kirkdale do not have the same services as other parts of the city, often accompanied by comments that they have lost various ones. It is true they have but the services that were in the area were there to serve a large community both residential and industrial. When the infrastructure needs replacing or cuts need to be made, Kirkdale's reduced population meant that it didn't have a large enough population to justify the services. So whether they be council or private businesses they either closed down or moved out. If you want them back then you need a bigger population and that will not happen with bungalows and semi-detached houses.


Looking north

A recent planning application 17F/0587 has caused a lot of debate, one organisation, whose HQ is opposite the proposed site, it is to the left of the above image, put up the following tweet.
It uses some interesting phrases "absent landlord", I'll assume this is shorthand for "Absentee landlord", this in a derogatory sense applied to 2 groups, one is landlords who rent out their property but do not ensure the maintenance of the property, they are absent from the life of the property, not simply absent from the local area. The other is to do with the large holdings in Ireland granted during the plantation of Ireland to English landlords who simply rented out the entire holding and still resided in England and simply took the wealth out of Ireland and spent it in England.
The term is not really applicable in either sense here as the owners of these properties have to release them on a regular basis if they fall into disappear people will go elsewhere. It also unclear how they are irresponsible.
The other claim is that they are putting "profit before people", this kind of phrase was often used when dangerous working practices cause harm to employees or to the surrounding people. It is not entirely clear which people are being harmed by this building. Sure some do not want the building but that doesn't really constitute meaningful harm especially when the site being taken is far from unique.
Apparently "Kirkdale is an inclusive community" this quite clearly questionable as one of the things that have come up is that the locals want to control who comes into their area when that was suggested it garnered at least one like.
Students seem to attract a particular ire, it is interesting to ask why someone who had ambitions for their children who wanted them to get an education and get on would look at their children and see potential students but in this area, they seem almost a different species something that is nothing to do with them.
While I haven't seen it mentioned in this context yet, gentrification seems to be one of the fears of the community. Gentrification, where is it bad, is where it forces out those already resident in an area, it would take a lot of building in the Kirkdale ward before there was any chance of the locals being pushed out. The only building in Kirkdale at the moment could never be described as gentrification it simple regeneration of derelict land.
"real people" was another term used this is a worrying phrase at it suggests there are some non-real people, people who are in someone way fake or fraudulent and don't require being treated like "real people" it is a horrible phrase which covers up all sorts of bigotries and hatred. It is a phrase that UKIP & the EDL like to use when differentiating their knuckle-dragging followers from those they see as "the urban elite". Controlling who moves into your area is not usually something associated with inclusive communities.
One of the other phrases used as criticism was "multi-storey" anything over a bungalow is "multi-storey", in this case, the proposed development is the same height as the surrounding buildings, though being flat-roofed it fits in one more habitable floor but, this makes it the dread "multi-storey". The phrase is used to conjure up images of the 15 storey buildings that were badly built in the 1960s, some were awful but a lot were simply trashed by the locals.
What are the elected representatives of the area doing to illustrate the contradictions in what the residents have said they want, well it seems nothing. Instead, they seem intent on blocking development and possibly incurring extra expenses for the council. The recent blocking of application 17F/0441, a modest affair on Scotland road was blocked against the advice of the Planning Dept on what seems spurious ground, any appeal outside the council will all most certainly to succeed but will, of course, cost everyone involve cash, but it will allow the councillors to say look at what we did. In the case of 17F/0441, no locals registered objections with the council.


Some have suggested the site should be a Village Green, this is a bit of problem as Kirkdale is not a village but I think it gives an insight into the mind of some of the protestors, they want a return to the rural life in Cranford et al. but of course those are fictional sugar-coated idealisations, which never existed. While it might be difficult for us to understand today but the reason people moved to the horrors of Victorian Cities from the countryside was that life was actually better in the cities. Even today being poor in the countryside is probably worse than in the city, as everything is more expensive or far further away and the transport is very bad. What cities have is not village greens but squares like Abercromby Square and Falkner Square with gardens at the heart of them.

The future

This entire episode looks like a massive combination of childishness, NIMBYism all tied up with inverse snobbery. Individuals have conflicting ambitions and like children will not give up any but simply insist they should get there way. There is an unhealthy chunk of small-minded isolationism when it comes to people who might possibly be from a different socio-economic group. There is a complete lack of leadership from elected representatives, who know that their best chance of keeping votes is just to play along as they think the locals can be fobbed off with blaming others when their plans trip each other up.
It is pretty appalling and is not good for the city, the residents of Kirkdale want their own "managed decline" well if they want to live in the suburbs or the countryside perhaps they should go and live there. Kirkdale's location within the city determines what its inner-city nature should be, that is what made it what it was and defines what it needs to be, the city as a whole will have to decide to end the selfish NIMBY attitude surrounding the area for good and have to expose the self-serving attitude of those who seek to be community leaders exposed.
The community is a fractious one the Eldonian Village Hall was burnt down in an arson attack, I do not think anyone was prosecuted but the suspicion was that it was connected to some internecine rivalries. Who knows how many people are for or against this development, it is only the loudest voices the can be heard and they seem to hail from a far wider area than just Kirkdale.


This application was turned down today.